Recently, I came across a debate on Twitter where fans compared visuals from Sonic Unleashed and Sonic Frontiers. I also chimed in on the debate, here's my Twitter post.
One post highlighted the vibrant, stylized brilliance of Unleashed — a game over a decade old. Another tried to counter with a screenshot from Frontiers featuring ultra-realistic scenery, complete with lush greenery and reflective water.
But the contrast wasn't flattering. If anything, it proved a deeper truth about game design: fidelity alone isn't enough. Art direction is what gives a game its soul.
You can crank up realism all you want, but without soul, it's just noise. Sonic's world was never about photorealism. It was about vibrance, motion, energy. It popped. It pulled you in.
This Frontiers screenshot is realistic, sure. But flat. Lifeless. Like it was built to show off a graphics engine and forgot it's supposed to be a game.
Frontiers looks real for realism's sake, without asking if that look serves Sonic's identity. It tries to emulate the real world, but forgets how Sonic games feel. What made Sonic unforgettable wasn't how real the grass looked, it was how alive the world felt. Colors had character.
When fidelity drowns out personality, you get environments that impress in stills but evaporate in motion.
This isn't immersion. It's impersonation. The series went from crafting worlds with heart to building landscapes with resolution.
Think back to Sonic Adventure. Emerald Coast wasn't just a beach. It was color, motion, energy. Rolling waves. Pastel skies. Killer whales leaping through shimmering water. Cinematic. Not photorealistic. Even Adventure 2's City Escape, with exaggerated hues and manic momentum, felt electric. Stylized. Reactive. Unforgettable.
Sonic has always thrived in worlds where style fuels gameplay. Where design shouts louder than detail.
If realism were a flex, movies would stop using color grading, artists would abandon style, and animation would cease to exist.
This isn't evolution. It's erosion. The art direction got sidelined. The game lost its heartbeat.
Sonic Unleashed delivered high fidelity visuals that still felt stylized and alive. It looked real without sacrificing the vibrant identity that defines Sonic.
If Sonic Adventure could deliver unforgettable vibes on a Dreamcast, what's Frontiers' excuse on modern hardware?
Final Thoughts
This post isn't about dunking on a single game. It's about preserving what makes a franchise memorable. Sonic's legacy was built on speed, style, and worlds that felt fantastical. When realism overtakes soul, even a technically impressive game can feel hollow.
Let me know what you think. Does style matter more to you than realism in games? Should Sonic lean back into bold art direction again?
